Did Vatican II Teach Infallibly?
The Ordinary and Universal Magisterium
by John S. Daly
Second, Revised Edition
First printed in The Four Marks
Album / Alamy Stock Photo
Most traditional Catholics know that Vatican II taught heresies and other errors. They rightly refuse to accept this false teaching. But when asked how it can be right to reject the teaching of a General Council of the Catholic Church, they reply that Vatican II was a special kind of council; it was non-dogmatic and non-infallible. As such it could err, and did err, and Catholics may reject its errors without doubting the legitimacy of the authority that promulgated those errors.